Cliff Diving Into TSP℠: How Watts Humphrey saved a third-year software engineering lab course in Rajasthan’s LNMIIT

July, 2020

The July 2020 Tech Talk was presented by Dr. Philip Miller

Abstract:

With no more than a university course information form and list of the names of software projects from a previous course offering, the author, a Visiting Professor at LNMIIT, decided that TSP was his best chance at giving students a useful experience in teaming software development.  Students had no prior training in TSP℠, PSP℠, or software engineering.  There was no coordination with a concurrent software engineering theory course. There were 215 students. Prior work with 200 of the university’s students in an intermediate C programming course indicated serious gaps in knowledge and skill sets. The author was the only faculty member involved. There were no teaching assistants. This had all the ingredients necessary for an educational disaster.  Surprisingly the course was judged a great success by the students, the author, most of the faculty who paid attention to the course, and the University Director, a very high quality tenured professor of computer science on loan from BITS Pilani. 

How can we account for such an unlikely outcome? Watts Humphrey was a genius. Students worked harder, with more cohesion and to greater effect than anyone expected. Support from the top was excellent. Requiring all 21 of the student software teams to adhere to TSP orthodoxy on open source projects of their own choosing were good ideas, really good ideas. Treating the students as young professionals was rewarded with them behaving exactly like that – young, sincere professionals. The course was a joy. Watts would have loved it even though the author broke rule after rule after rule. Data and details will be presented.

About the Presenter 

Dr. Philip Miller has been working on one, and only one thing since entering the field of computer science as special faculty in the Computer Science Department of Carnegie Mellon University in 1979. That thing is to extend the excitement, benefits and blessings of knowledge, skills and careers in computing to people who could use some help. In the 1980s pursuit of that objective led to leadership in creating Advanced Placement Computer Science for the College Board and leveraging money from Steve Jobs and the National Science Foundation into novice programming environments that dominated American university freshman programming courses for a half decade or so. In the 1990s the pursuit was manifest in iCarnegie, a CMU backed startup that used blended learning to bring high quality curriculum and superb instructor preparation and support to hundreds of thousands of learners around the globe at prices more than an order of magnitude lower than a CMU education.

Being a slow learner it was well into the 2000s before Dr. Miller figured out that even very well trained people weren’t going to get jobs so long as the software companies proudly spouted things like, “We only hire from the top 20 universities!” It was another year or two before he realized that “authentic examination”, certifying personal software skills in the context of working on real systems was the key to leveling the playing field while at the same time identifying qualified developers for a global industry that was chronically starved for human capital. The World Bank loved the idea. As Dr. Miller waited for the several years that it took Carnegie Mellon and the World Bank to work out the details that made it possible for the former to accept money from the latter, Dr. Miller became a TSP Coach. Breathtaking is the only way that Dr. Miller describes the success of TSP in his coaching experiences. The confluence of authentic examination and disciplined, empirically based software development has Dr. Miller on his current quest to remove the inefficiencies in both training and hiring.

His PhD thesis (Political Science, Ohio State, 1976 ) used Lebesgue measure theory and Alfred Tarski’s notion of models of formal theory to analyze and extend the existing body of spatial theories of voter choice.

℠ Personal Software Process, PSP, Team Software Process, and TSP are service marks of Carnegie Mellon University. The Software Excellence Alliance is not affiliated with Carnegie Mellon University.

Past Presentations

Why Battle-Tested Software Engineering Still Matters in the Age of AI

The June 2026 Tech Talk was presented by Mario BenitezAbstractWhile use of AI in developing and maintaining software is increasing globally, this use is relatively new, and proven practices for using AI effectively are still emerging. There are different ways to use...

The SEA Data Warehouse

The April 2026 Tech Talk announced the availability of the SEA Data WarehouseAbstractThe Data Warehouse Working Group was initiated in September 2022, with the purpose of advancing the state of the practice and the art of software engineering by providing a source of...

Agentic Coding: The Earthquake That Topples the Software Factory

The March 2026 Tech Talk was presented by Larry MaccheroneAbstractThe tectonic plates beneath software development are shifting. They are moving too fast to predict what the landscape will look like when the earthquake hits. Still, we are sure that the coming...

Why Program Increment Estimates Miss: Hidden Variables for Planning

The February 2026 Tech Talk was presented by Dr. Bill Nichols and Dr. Tapajit Dey AbstractWhat is a credible range of dates for when the work in a product increment might finish? Software development work includes many sources of uncertainty, including the size of the...

Lessons from Using LLMs to Check Software Security

The January 2026 Tech Talk was presented by Dr. Mark ShermanAbstractLarge language models (LLMs) like ChatGPT are transforming the landscape of software development and evaluation, although claims of AI replacing programmers are often overstated. This session delves...

Process Isn’t a Four-Letter Word

The November 2025 Tech Talk was presented by David TumaAbstractAgile methods emerged as a direct rebellion against the heavyweight processes of the 1990s. And the Team Software Process (TSP) did too, by brilliantly reimagining process in a lightweight, agile way that...

Agile Strategy: Onward and Upward

The September 2025 Tech Talk was presented by Linda Parker GatesAbstractThis talk describes the application of Agile principles to strategic planning. It explores how applying balanced Agile values — such as prioritizing individuals and interactions, delivering...

Engineering of Complex Systems at NAVAIR: We Must Do More With Less!

The June 2025 tech talk was presented by Jeff SchwalbAbstractAt NAVAIR, we are experiencing a dwindling engineering workforce at the same time that we are trying to meet increasing demands for support to our warfighters. We have a combination of efforts uplifting the...

Victims vs. Victors: Navigating Career Uncertainty with Resilience

The May 2025 tech talk was presented by David VanEppsAbstractSetbacks are inevitable. Travel freezes, budget cuts, hiring slowdowns, layoffs — challenges like these can shake our sense of stability. While we can’t always control what happens, we can control how we...

Applying STPA to Improve Safety and Reliability of AI-Enabled Systems

The April 2025 tech talk was presented by Timothy DavisonAbstractThis talk explores the application of System-Theoretic Process Analysis (STPA) to enhance the safety and reliability of AI-enabled systems. STPA provides a structured and scalable approach to identifying...

Drive Improved Holistic Business Results with Lean/Agile Practices

The February 2025 tech talk was presented by Fred KoosAbstractAgile practices have roots in Lean Thinking and the Toyota Production System. These are holistic approaches to improve business results. As the word “Agile” was coined in 2001, the applications were...

Clarify Your Acceptance Criteria with GIVEN-WHEN-THEN

The January 2025 tech talk was presented by Matt McConnellAbstractGherkin, also known as GIVEN-WHEN-THEN, is an effective method for writing Acceptance Criteria at many levels in software development. It treats the software as a black box, focusing on the inputs,...

A Powerfully Simple Planning Framework

The December 2024 tech talk was presented by Dr. Brad HodginsAbstractUsing this very effective five-step approach, teams and individuals can create a detailed plan that will enable them to track their progress as they execute that plan. Organizations run on schedules...

Share This